Extractive Enterprise versus Agrarian Enterprise Symbiosis

28 June 2000

Last week we looked at a couple of examples of individuals engaged in the process of enterprise symbiosis. This week we will look more at the traditional concept of enterprise, that dealing with our work enterprise whether that be corporate, as an independent business owner, or an employee.

Western command and control enterprises are, in essence, of the extractive nature. To say it a different way, they are mining companies. They may not take minerals from the earth but they extract their wealth from other sources of resources. For ten years I ran a company that manufactured gold mining equipment. A common saying in the gold mining business is, "A gold mine is a hole you pour money into." If you pour in just a little more money you will hit the mother lode and all your problems will cease. The internet dotcoms are examples of extractive businesses designed to mine money from people who use the internet. Just like most precious metals projects, most will just end up being dry holes. More traditional businesses look at all aspects of their business to extract wealth. That may be the employees and/or the customers, suppliers and business partners. Wealth is built on the backs of these sources of human capital. If you feel you are being used as an earth mover, to move a ton of dirt to extract less than an ounce of gold you probably work for such an organization. Because according to the Bible we were created to be gardeners, it is no wonder you are sometimes distressed and depressed. Many times getting back to what you were created to do, in the way you were created to do it, is the only solution to this complex problem.

To find a natural example of this quarrying form of enterprise, you need only look at the conifer trees. Firs, pine and spruce being the example. The central trunk is the most important aspect of the tree. It is the part that man finds of value. From the trunks of conifer trees we build our houses and other structures, symbolizing also our business morphology. In the recent antitrust case with Microsoft both the government and Microsoft were truly arguing about the structure of the central trunk of the corporation. Microsoft arguing that without maintaining this viable trunk infrastructure the core of the company would be severely impacted in its continued ability to grow. The business hierarchy must be maintained at all cost.

Except for some small family and organic farms, we really no longer find examples of agrarian enterprise symbiosis. For most modern agribusiness is truly just an agrarian method of mining the wealth of the soil, with little understanding of the symbiotic process. No matter what it costs, just pour in more money and charge the customers more and we get richer and to hell with every one else. Perhaps however, the saddest examples come from the health care industry and the church. HMO's and related service providers are now more interested in the bottom line than providing compassionate health care. TBN and other church organization raise money from the sheep by shearing the sheep of some of their financial wool to build another trunk infrastructure, with the concept of winning souls for Jesus, adapting extractive enterprise to God's agrarian work. I have just come to realize that one of the reasons for the failure of my mining adventure, was that it essentially used an agrarian model in a truly extractive business. I still think that it could work, but not without fully understanding and utilizing the symbiosis model.

Fruit and nut deciduous trees are the natural examples of a symbiotic enterprise, or the centerless enterprise, we discussed in earlier weeks. The trunk is not all that important compared to the branches and the fruit. The orchardist, prunes the branches to produce more branches and more and better fruit. But beyond that the harvest is beyond the control of management. The Lord, or if you prefer nature provides the increase. Where in a typical corporate environment with the application of more capital (human or financial) can bring a discernible increase, cause and effect, in the symbiotic enterprise more capital may reduce or eliminate the crop entirely. This can of course also effect the true quality of the fruit the husbandman was trying to secure. Before we continue also remember it is generally from deciduous trees where we secure our most beautiful wood, but it is from the conifers where we harvest our structural framing resources.

The Bible is a book of agrarian enterprise symbiosis. It has virtually nothing to say about building a hierarchy for man's endeavors. Perhaps God knew that we could do this all right by ourselves, or perhaps he new no matter what He said we would go our own way no matter God's plan. In any event, the centerless enterprise has concepts of spirituality and faith that a modern corporate structure cannot stand. Agrarian enterprise must be built on plowing, sowing, fertilizing and waiting for the harvest in season. The seasons cannot be rushed by more and bigger applications of capital.

In Genesis Chapter 2:10-12 we find the first mention of agrarian and extracted resource enterprises: Now a river went out of Eden to water the garden, and from there it parted and became four riverheads. The name of the first is Pishon, it is the one which skirts the whole land of Havilah were there is gold. And the gold of that land is good. Bdellium (a gum resin) and the onyx stone are there.

Most of the leaders of the Biblical line leading from Adam to Jesus were from agrarian stock. Long times with the herds gave Moses and David the ability to lead God's people well. We now substitute many formal years of 'book learnin' and wonder why there is no true leadership in any of our enterprise. If we truly want to understand our role in enterprise symbiosis, we must spend some time with the Good Book and herding of flocks in the wilderness or things will continue to loose there footing in the real world and we will be left with nothing but shallow meaningless self seeking and serving enterprise. Before the whole thing collapses under its own weight.

PRAYER PLANTS

Over the last week things sure got a whole lot more complicated, well beyond my ability to put the pieces together in the right order at the right time, but I strongly feel that this path is the one which I should follow. The gentleman I called last week about the property did not return my call and I called him again Monday to see what was going on. As I send this, I still have not heard a thing from him. I also ran across another ranch with more agricultural potential and about the same size for a whole lot less money. But if it were to be used for a retreat center some buildings would have to be build or a different scope would have to be determined. Continued intercessory prayer is requested.